Every business owner chasing visibility on Google Maps faces the same challenge: reviews. They are one of the most powerful ranking signals and one of the first things potential customers notice. But here is the dilemma, what carries more weight, the number of reviews or the average star rating?
Imagine two businesses:
- Business A has twenty-five reviews, all five stars.
- Business B has three hundred reviews, averaging 4.4 stars.
Which one do you think ranks higher? Which one do customers choose? The answer is not as simple as picking one factor over the other. Google, and the people searching, look at both but in quite diverse ways.
Why Reviews Are Crucial for Google Maps SEO
Before diving into volume vs. rating, let us be clear on why reviews matter so much. Google Maps results are driven by three pillars: relevance, proximity, and prominence. Reviews directly influence the last two:
- Prominence: Lots of reviews show your business is established and well-known.
- Relevance (indirectly): When reviews mention services, products, or neighborhoods, they reinforce what you do and where you do it.
- User Behavior: More reviews = more clicks, more calls, more visits. Google tracks this engagement and uses it to reorder rankings.
So, reviews are not just popularity contests. They are an SEO tool, a trust signal, and a customer conversion driver rolled into one.
The Power of Review Volume
Volume is the first thing people notice, “Wow, this place has 500 reviews.” That number alone builds instant authority.
Why volume matters:
- Signals activity: A steady stream of recent reviews tells Google your business is alive and serving customers now.
- Builds social proof: Shoppers trust businesses more when many people have vouched for them.
- Boosts keyword density: Reviews often include service-related terms (“roof repair,” “AC installation”), which strengthens your local relevance.
Example:
A café with four hundred reviews averaging 4.2 stars will often outrank a café with only twenty reviews averaging 4.9 stars. Why? Because volume tells Google, and potential customers, that the first café is more widely chosen and established.
The Importance of Review Rating
While volume builds credibility, rating builds confidence. Customers filter out low scores instantly, no matter how many reviews a business has.
Why rating matters:
- Trust and perception: People rarely click businesses with less than 3.5 stars.
- Direct impact on conversions: A strong rating drives calls, bookings, and visits.
- Differentiator: If two businesses have similar review counts, the higher rating usually wins the click.
Example:
Two electricians each have ~100 reviews. One averages 4.8, the other 3.6. Guess who gets more calls? Even if the 3.6 electrician ranks in Maps, users often skip over them in favor of the competitor.
Review Volume vs. Rating: Which Does Google Care About More?
Here is the key insight: Google uses review volume more for rankings, and rating more for user choice.
- Volume = visibility. The more reviews you have, the more signals Google gets that you are established.
- Rating = conversions. The higher your score, the more likely customers are to click and act.
This explains why a business with hundreds of reviews and a 4.3 average can outrank a smaller competitor with twenty perfect reviews. But once both listings show up, the one with the higher rating often attracts more clicks.
Google wants to balance both signals. It favors businesses that are both popular and trustworthy—but if they must choose, prominence (volume) usually outweighs a near-perfect rating.
The Psychology of Customers: What They Value
Let us not forget that SEO only gets people to see you. The real goal is to get them to choose you.
What customers look for:
- Critical mass: A single five-star review is not convincing. Customers want to see a base level of feedback, usually at least 20–30 reviews.
- Consistency: They scan repeated themes. Ten people mentioning “slow service” sticks out.
- Recency: A review from last week feels more relevant than one from 2019.
- Balance: A profile with nothing but perfect 5-stars can feel fake. A mix of 4s and 5s looks authentic.
At Oastreck, we provide numerous services to help your business outstand in the market. Check out Oastreck’s services:
- Website SEO: Unlock visibility with search engine optimization (SEO)
- Google Ads PPC: Turn clicks into customers with expert PPC management!
- Web Design & Development: Craft Digital Excellence
- Google Maps Management: Optimized business listing for local search
- And much more!
We provide the best facilities for businesses. Our local expertise with global reach and impactful success stories proves our ambition of helping businesses grow. We work via a five-step process including a discovery call, business audit, best solutions, contract details and finally the execution. Give a call today to get your First FREE AUDIT.
We at Oastreck focus on making local service businesses appear in the Map Pack through profile optimization, reputation building, and website alignment with Google’s local ranking signals. If your business is not appearing, we can help.
So, while volume might pull you up in rankings, customers still look at your score, your latest reviews, and the overall story your profile tells.
How to Balance Review Volume and Rating
If you want to win in Google Maps SEO, you cannot lean too hard on just one side. You need both. Here is how:
- Make asking a habit
After every job or visit, ask for a review. Text or email customers with your Google link. Volume builds slowly but steadily. - Respond to everything
Reply to all reviews, good or bad. Google rewards active profiles, and customers respect businesses that engage. - Do not chase perfection
A rating between 4.3 and 4.8 is ideal. Too low hurts conversions: a perfect 5.0 with low volume can look suspicious. - Fix the leaks
If bad reviews keep coming, do not just push for more volume. Find the root cause—poor service, long waits, miscommunication—and solve it. - Highlight helpful reviews
Share them on social media, embed them on your site, and let them reinforce your credibility beyond Maps.
Common Myths About Reviews
- Myth: A single critical review ruins your rating.
Not true. One negative review among dozens of positives barely dents your average. - Myth: You need 5.0 stars to rank.
False. Some of the highest-ranking businesses sit comfortably at 4.4–4.7. - Myth: Review volume does not matter if your rating is high.
Wrong. Google wants proof you are active. Ten perfect reviews cannot compete with hundreds of mixed ones.
People Also Ask (PAA)
Do more reviews help me rank higher on Google Maps?
Yes. Review volume is strongly tied to visibility in the Map Pack.
Is a high rating more important than lots of reviews?
A high rating helps with customer trust, but for rankings, volume usually matters more.
What is the best strategy to optimize my business local search?
Get as many reviews as possible while keeping your average ratings above 4.3 stars.
How many reviews should I aim for to sustain my business profile?
Research shows businesses with 100+ reviews consistently outrank those with fewer than 20. However, there is no specific number.
Conclusion
So, review volume vs. rating—what matters more in Google Maps?
- For Google’s algorithm: review volume carries more weight.
- For customers choosing you: rating plays a bigger role.
The sweet spot is both. Aim for steady review growth, encourage delighted customers to share their experience, and protect your rating by solving problems quickly.
So, reviews are not just SEO tricks, they are the online reputation of your business. Build both the volume and the quality, and your Google Maps presence will take care of itself.
If you’re looking for an agency that understands real-world business, book a free strategy call and get your Free Audit today. No pressure. Just clarity.
